Which of the following is NOT an example of a fixture?

A fixture is defined as a piece of personal property that has been attached to the real property in such a way that it becomes part of that property. When determining whether something is a fixture, the key factors to consider include the method of attachment, the character of the item, and the intention of the parties involved.

The cast iron garden bench is an example of personal property that is not permanently affixed to the land or the structures on it; therefore, it does not meet the criteria for being considered a fixture. It can typically be moved without damaging the property, which supports its classification as movable personal property.

In contrast, the antique chandelier is usually mounted to the ceiling and is typically intended to remain in place, making it a fixture. The hot water heater is installed and connected to the plumbing system and is designed to stay put, fulfilling the definition of a fixture. The heirloom rosebush, while it might be movable, is considered to be part of the real estate as it is rooted in the ground and not intended to be relocated.

Thus, the correct choice showcases an item that does not adhere to the definition of a fixture, affirming its classification as personal property instead.